Functional crosswalk
Compare without flattening.
The same functional questions are applied to different architectures while their native terms remain intact.
Comparative inquiry
What is composed—and what actually runs?
A high-level crosswalk; the detailed ten-field record for each system is on its own model page.
| Model | Meaning | Composition mechanism | Operation | Present standing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CE-XTG-01 XTechGroup | Composition means selecting, arranging and relating functional instruments and treatments for a bounded situation, rather than running every capability universally. | Characterize the operative field, identify the active burden, select and qualify suitable capabilities, then construct a workstream with explicit relationships. | A selected path may invoke analytical tools, human decisions, conventional functions or other processing; full automated implementation is not established. | Working architecture with dated documentation; multiple mechanisms remain developmental and should not be represented as a verified deployed engine. |
| CE-MS-01 Microsoft | Composition means managing and combining graphics resources and related rendering structures into a visual representation. | Combine and update resources under a coherent graphics composition mechanism. | Rendering-related processing yields an updated composed scene; not a general business workflow executor. | Published granted patent in a technically different field. Not evidence of a cross-domain inquiry system. |
| CE-MS-02 Microsoft | Composition is a formal operation that builds a structured business model using elements drawn from other business models. | Select compatible or relevant portions of multiple models and formally combine them into another model. | Operates on model representations; execution of the businesses being modeled is not itself established by the compose operator. | Published application; source record identifies it as abandoned. Disclosure remains relevant as prior art. |
| CE-IBM-01 IBM | Composition creates an operative analytical arrangement whose components are bound to defined analytical models. | Create model composition definitions, receive a composition, then bind it to available model definitions. | The claimed method concerns execution of composed analytical models, not merely a visualization. | Granted patent with published application available. A patent is disclosure, not proof of a specific production deployment. |
| CE-SAP-01 SAP | Composition derives coordinated activities and potential parallel control flows from object lifecycles and relationships. | Compute actions and their conditions from states/transitions; derive inter-action relations; generate parallel process fragments. | Generates process models that can support parallel execution; model generation must be distinguished from runtime enactment. | Granted patent and published disclosure; operational deployment not established by this record. |
| CE-CUM-01 Cumulus Digital Systems | Composition converts natural-language task intent into structured workflow steps under an explicit schema. | Generate schema-conforming workflow content from the task instructions, optionally drawing on supplementary documents. | Workflow generation is disclosed; execution of every generated step is not necessarily part of the claimed method. | Granted patent, with published application. Verify claims separately from descriptive embodiments. |
| CE-SN-01 ServiceNow | Composition begins with a proposed workflow structure that is iteratively refined and converted into a more complete workflow. | Construct placeholder activities and their properties, then allow editing, substitution and approval. | Generates usable workflow structures; specific runtime invocation lies in a later operational step. | Published application (pending according to source record); do not treat all descriptive mechanisms as granted claims. |
| CE-INT-01 GE Financial / Genworth | Composition assembles a situation-dependent sequence of questions from declared rules and prior answers. | A selected answer indexes a branching rule, which determines the subsequent question and script path. | The system runs the interview interactively and can record results. | Granted patent; a direct early precedent for interactive question-path control. |
Functional Trust perspective
The four-row assessment.
A comparative instrument, not an assertion that every system natively implements all four rows.
| Model | Narrative | Logic | Transaction | Operations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CE-XTG-01 | Purpose and situated inquiry model | Selected relationships, rules and control dynamics | Explicit changes, admissions and acceptance | Selected treatments, construction and execution |
| CE-MS-01 | Scene/visual task, not general inquiry | Graphical constraints and resource relationships | Resource update/change handling | Composition and rendering |
| CE-MS-02 | Representation of business capability | Mapping, constraints and formal operators | Model manipulation, not claimed business commitment | Model combination and refinement |
| CE-IBM-01 | Desired analytical task | Model definitions and binding compatibility | Binding/execution state; further review needed | Composed analytical execution |
| CE-SAP-01 | Business objective reflected in process model | Action relations and preconditions/effects | Object state transitions | Parallel process fragment generation |
| CE-CUM-01 | Task description from a person | Predefined workflow schema | Not central in abstracted method | LLM workflow generation/display |
| CE-SN-01 | Natural-language workflow intent | Activity properties, rules and triggers | Human revision/approval of skeleton | Workflow construction, later runtime |
| CE-INT-01 | Purpose of the customer interview | Branch tables and answer selection | Capture and retention of responses | Interactive question presentation |
Evaluation rule
A named component, a described claim, a validated implementation and a demonstrated outcome are different forms of Standing. Do not promote one into another without evidence.
Ten fields
The shared record schema.
Keep each model’s original structure while asking comparable engineering questions.
01 · IdentityWhat model and publication?
02 · MeaningWhat is composition here?
03 · PurposeWhich problem is addressed?
04 · ElementsWhat components participate?
05 · StructureHow are they organized and related?
06 · CompositionHow is a larger whole constructed?
07 · OperationWhat actually executes?
08 · ResultsWhat is produced or changed?
09 · AssuranceWhat can be verified or relied on?
10 · StandingWhat is documented, implemented or demonstrated?